The following is an index to property transfer deeds and agreements recorded at the Suffolk County Deed Registry from the original land purchase through September 30, 2019. Mortgages, trust agreements, and other similar recorded documents are not included. This index is intended as a guide only; actual deeds should be reviewed for details.
| Transfers of Land and Buildings | ||||
| Date of Deed | Grantor | Grantee | Book | Page |
| 23Jun1960 | The First Baptist Society in Boston | First Baptist Church of Boston | 7506 | 469 |
| 04Apr1900 | Elisha James, Daniel C. Linscott, Rest F. Curtis, George F. D. Paine, Frank H. Dean, Alfred D. Flinn, and Henry S. Parsons, Deacons of the First Baptist Church in Boston | The First Baptist Society in Boston | 2703 | 593 |
| 29Mar1882 | Joshua M. Sears | Cyrus Carpenter, John Q. A Litchfield, Elisha James, Samuel S. Cudworth, Lansing Mills, and James W. Converse, Deacons of the First Baptist Church in Boston | 1555 | 41 |
| 28May1881 | Proprietors of the Church in Brattle Square | Joshua M. Sears | 1526 | 98 |
| Transfers of Unimproved Land: Lot with 116 foot frontage at southwest corner of Commonwealth and Clarendon | ||||
| Date of Deed | Grantor | Grantee | Book | Page |
| 29Jun1872 | Franklin Haven and John Gardner; and Samuel P. Hammatt, Albert T. P. Ames, and Ebenezer Dale, trustees under the will of Ebenezer Dale (lot with 116 foot frontage) | Proprietors of the Church in Brattle Square | 1128 | 176 |
| 01Oct1866 (recorded 8Nov1872) | Commonwealth of Massachusetts (lot with 28 foot frontage) | Franklin Haven, Ebenezer Dale, and John Gardner | 1133 | 242 |
| 01Oct1866 (recorded 8Nov1872) | Commonwealth of Massachusetts (lot with 28 foot frontage) | Franklin Haven, Ebenezer Dale, and John Gardner | 1133 | 241 |
| 01Oct1866 (recorded 8Nov1872) | Commonwealth of Massachusetts (lot with 32 foot frontage) | Franklin Haven, Ebenezer Dale, and John Gardner | 1133 | 238 |
| 01Oct1866 (recorded 8Nov1872) | Commonwealth of Massachusetts (lot with 28 foot frontage) | Franklin Haven, Ebenezer Dale, and John Gardner | 1133 | 237 |
| Transfers of Unimproved Land: Lot with 28 foot frontage to the east of 114 Commonwealth | ||||
| Date of Deed | Grantor | Grantee | Book | Page |
| 10Jul1882 | William G. Weld | Cyrus Carpenter, John Q. A Litchfield, Elisha James, Lansing Mills, and James W. Converse, Deacons of the First Baptist Church in Boston | 1566 | 550 |
| 10Jul1882 | Commonwealth of Massachusetts (lot with 28 foot frontage) | William G. Weld | 1566 | 547 |
| Transfers of Unimproved Land: Strip of land 6 inches wide with half of the eastern party wall of 114 Commonwealth on it | ||||
| Date of Deed | Grantor | Grantee | Book | Page |
| 18Jul1882 | David H. Coolidge (6 inch strip of land with eastern half of the eastern party wall on it) | Cyrus Carpenter, John Q. A Litchfield, Elisha James, Samuel S. Cudworth, Lansing Mills, and James W. Converse, Deacons of the First Baptist Church in Boston | 1567 | 567 |
| 13Mar1880 | William S. Rand | David H. Coolidge | 1486 | 218 |
| 13Mar1880 | Henry L. Daggett | William S. Rand | 1486 | 1486 |
| 23Jul1879 | Francis Bartlett and Francis V. Balch, trustees under the will of Francis W. Sayles | Henry L. Daggett | 1463 | 223 |
| 27Oct1875 | Edward I. Browne and Henry Sayles, outgoing trustees under the will of Francis W. Sayles, and James A. Dupee, late trustee under said will | Francis Bartlett and Francis B. Balch, successor trustees under the will of Francis W. Sayles | 1311 | 9 |
| 10Mar1869 | William G. Weld | James A. Dupee and Henry Sayles, trustees under the will of Francis W. Sayles | 954 | 98 |
| 15Feb1869 | William Munroe | William G. Weld | 951 | 291 |
| 28May1868 | Commonwealth of Massachusetts (lot with 28 foot frontage) | William Munroe | 930 | 178 |
| Preservation Restriction Agreement: Agreement by the First Baptist Church of Boston with the Massachusetts Historical Commission that “no alterations shall be made to the premises, including the alteration of any interior, unless (a) clearly of a minor nature and not affecting the characteristics which contribute to the architectural, archaeological or historical integrity of the premises, or (b) the Commission has previously determined that it will not impair such characteristics after reviewing plans and specifications submitted by the Grantor, or (c ) required by casualty or other emergency promptly reported to the Commission, or (d) interior changes for religious purposes that do not adversely impact the historically significant architectural, archeologica or hisorical characteristics of the Premises.” | ||||
| Date of Deed | Grantor | Grantee | Book | Page |
| 04Sep2019 | First Baptist Church of Boston | Massachusetts Historical Commission | 61747 | 199 |